Best Under Eye Pencil – Top Picks & Guide

Ever look in the mirror and wish those tired shadows under your eyes would just disappear? We’ve all been there. That feeling of wanting to brighten up your gaze, but then staring at a wall of makeup products and feeling completely overwhelmed. Choosing the perfect under-eye pencil can feel like a quest for hidden treasure, with so many shades, formulas, and promises out there.

It’s tough to know which pencil will actually work, won’t smudge after an hour, or look cakey. You want something that makes you look refreshed and awake, not like you’ve tried too hard. This can leave you feeling frustrated and unsure of what to buy. But what if we told you that finding your dream under-eye pencil doesn’t have to be a mystery?

Keep reading, because in this post, we’re going to break down everything you need to know. We’ll help you understand what to look for, explore different types, and share tips so you can confidently pick a pencil that will make your eyes pop. Get ready to say goodbye to those under-eye worries!

Top Under Eye Pencil Recommendations

SaleNo. 1
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 201 Black, 2 pack | Waterproof pencil eyeliner with...
  • LASTING EYELINER: Rich color looks freshly applied all day long; transfer-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof and fade-proof
  • UP TO 24HR WEAR: Creates the look you want and stays on strong
  • EASY APPLICATION: Pencil eyeliner glides on, creating intensely defined lines that can go from subtle to dramatic. Includes built-in sharpener for the perfect pointed tip and a smudger to blend.
SaleNo. 2
wet n wild Color Icon Kohl Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Hyper-Pigmented Color, Smooth Creamy Application...
  • These long-wearing liners have rich, hyper-pigmented color, an oh-so-smooth, oh-so-creamy application, and are versatile enough to create any look you want
  • No wonder theyre so raved about by celebs and makeup artists
  • But dont worry, just because we're all Hollywood now doesnt mean we've forgotten about you
No. 3
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 202 Black Brown, 0.01 oz | Waterproof pencil eyeliner...
  • LASTING EYELINER: Rich color looks freshly applied all day long; transfer-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof and fade-proof
  • UP TO 24HR WEAR: Creates the look you want and stays on strong
  • EASY APPLICATION: Pencil eyeliner glides on, creating intensely defined lines that can go from subtle to dramatic. Includes built-in sharpener for the perfect pointed tip and a smudger to blend.
No. 4
Produco [thebom] AegyoSal Eyeliner Under-Eye Enhancing Pencil Highlighter Eye Makeup (2set) (Volume...
  • Long-Lasting: Long-wearing, fallout-free, smudge-proof eyeshadow all day. Blends smoothly around the eyes for a natural color effect.
  • Realistic Hue: Achieve a natural color, just like your real aegyo-sal.
  • Multi-use: eyeshadow, eyeliner, highlighter or shadowing, and Romantic Eye Effects with one product!
No. 5
3PCS Double Ended Under Eye Highlighter Pencil 2 Color Cream Eyeliner Stick
  • ❤【Dual-Ended Design】Teardrop-Shaped Double-Ended Eye Liner Pen for effortless under-eye brightening. The dual-tone highlighter features a teardrop-shaped tip that naturally accentuates and brightens the under-eye area, effortlessly creating a natural, plump under-eye effect to make your eyes appear larger. The soft yet firm brush on the other end blends the two shades seamlessly, creating a natural, graduated finish without harsh lines.
  • ❤【Smooth Creamy Texture】Formulated with a creamy, smooth texture, this under-eye contouring pencil glides on easily without smudging, fading, or caking. No creasing or settling into fine lines. The dual-ended design combines a dual-tone highlighter and a blending brush, allowing you to sculpt and shade the under-eye area for a natural and flawless look.
  • ❤【Long-Lasting & Waterproof】Waterproof and long-wearing, this eye brightening pencil stays put through sweat, humidity, and tears. Whether you're heading to a party, the gym, or a long day outdoors, your aegyo-sal and eye makeup remain vibrant and smudge-free. You don’t have to worry about touching up your makeup all day long.
No. 6
COLORGRAM Under Eye Highlighter Stick 03 Real Tone | Silky-Smooth Long-Lasting Highlighter...
  • ✨[Easy-to-Use, Double-Sided Design] Creating the perfect aegyo-sal has never been easier with our innovative double-sided highlighter stick. Designed for convenience, this product allows you to add depth with the shade liner and volume with the shadow/concealer. Achieve a natural and youthful look effortlessly, enhancing the beauty of your eyes with just a few simple steps.
  • ✨[Perfect Size for Precision Application] The COLORGRAM Under Eye Highlighter Stick is designed with precision in mind. Its compact size and ergonomic design make it perfect for applying in small, delicate areas like the under-eye region. The creamy formula melts into the skin and adheres smoothly, even in thin and wrinkled areas, ensuring a flawless finish every time. Enjoy the comfort of a light-weight, opaque glitter eye makeup that feels weightless on your skin.
  • ✨[Versatile and User-Friendly] Whether you're a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, our highlighter stick is designed to be versatile and user-friendly. It allows you to create a variety of looks with ease, from subtle daytime shimmer to bold evening glam. This all-in-one product is perfect for anyone looking to enhance their makeup routine with a simple yet effective tool.
No. 7
REVLON ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 201 Black, 0.01 oz | Waterproof pencil eyeliner with...
  • LASTING EYELINER: Rich color looks freshly applied all day long; transfer-proof, waterproof, smudge-proof and fade-proof
  • UP TO 24HR WEAR: Creates the look you want and stays on strong
  • EASY APPLICATION: Pencil eyeliner glides on, creating intensely defined lines that can go from subtle to dramatic. Includes built-in sharpener for the perfect pointed tip and a smudger to blend.
No. 8
2 PCS Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, Creamy Smooth Blendable Lying Silkworm Pencil, Under Eye Highlight...
  • ❤【Dual-Ended Design】This classic dual-ended pencil makes application effortless. One end features a dual-tone highlighter pencil that naturally brightens and defines the under-eye area, while the other end has a soft, yet firm brush that blends the color seamlessly for an even, natural finish.
  • ❤【Smooth Creamy Texture】This under-eye contouring pencil has a creamy, smooth texture that blends easily without smudging, fading or caking. Its dual-ended design combines highlighting and shading to help you achieve a sculpted under-eye contour.
  • ❤【Long-lasting & Waterproof】Our eye brightening pencil delivers long-lasting, waterproof functions, making it your go-to choice for eye makeup. Whether you're attending a party or heading outdoors, it stays put through sweat and water. You will achieve a long-lasting and beautiful look that keeps confident every day.

The Ultimate Buying Guide: Finding Your Perfect Under-Eye Pencil

Are you tired of dark circles or tired-looking eyes? An under-eye pencil can be your secret weapon! It’s a makeup tool that brightens and conceals, making your eyes pop. But with so many options, how do you pick the right one? This guide will help you find the best under-eye pencil for your needs.

Key Features to Look For

When choosing an under-eye pencil, keep these features in mind:

  • Shade Match: This is super important. You want a shade that’s one or two shades lighter than your skin tone. This helps to brighten the area. If it’s too light, it can look ashy. If it’s too dark, it won’t brighten.
  • Coverage: Do you need a little brightening or full-on concealer power? Pencils come with light, medium, or full coverage. Think about what you want to hide.
  • Finish: Some pencils have a matte finish, while others are creamy or shimmery. A matte finish looks natural. A creamy finish can be hydrating. A shimmery finish adds a bit of sparkle.
  • Longevity: You want a pencil that stays put all day. Look for formulas that are smudge-proof and waterproof. This means no touch-ups are needed.
  • Ease of Application: The pencil should glide on smoothly. It shouldn’t tug at your delicate under-eye skin. A good applicator or tip makes a big difference.

Important Materials

The ingredients in your under-eye pencil matter. Here are some to look for:

  • Hydrating Ingredients: Look for things like hyaluronic acid or glycerin. These keep your under-eye area moisturized. Dry skin can make fine lines look worse.
  • Pigments: These give the pencil its color and coverage. Good pigments will effectively cover dark circles.
  • Emollients: These are like softeners. They make the pencil feel smooth and easy to blend.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Several things make an under-eye pencil great or not so great:

What Makes it Better:

  • Smooth Formula: A pencil that blends easily without caking or settling into fine lines is a winner.
  • Good Pigmentation: Rich color means you don’t need to apply a lot to get the coverage you want.
  • Long-Wearing Formula: If it lasts all day without fading or creasing, it’s high quality.
  • Skin-Loving Ingredients: Formulas with added skincare benefits are a big plus.

What Makes it Worse:

  • Dry, Tuggy Formula: This can be uncomfortable and damage your skin.
  • Poor Shade Range: If it’s hard to find a match for your skin tone, it’s not a good product.
  • Creasing or Fading: If the color disappears or settles into lines quickly, it’s not worth the money.
  • Irritating Ingredients: Some formulas can cause redness or stinging.

User Experience and Use Cases

Using an under-eye pencil is usually pretty straightforward.

  • How to Use:

    1. Make sure your under-eye area is clean and moisturized.
    2. Apply the pencil directly to the dark areas or where you want to brighten.
    3. Use your finger, a brush, or a sponge to gently blend the product. Pat, don’t rub.
    4. You can use it alone or over concealer for extra coverage.
  • When to Use It:

    • Everyday Brightening: Use it to look more awake and refreshed on busy mornings.
    • Covering Dark Circles: It’s perfect for hiding sleep deprivation or genetic dark circles.
    • Highlighting: A lighter shade can be used to subtly highlight the inner corners of your eyes or your brow bone.
    • Correcting: Some pencils can help neutralize blue or purple tones under the eyes.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Under-Eye Pencils

Q: What is an under-eye pencil used for?

A: An under-eye pencil is used to brighten the skin under your eyes. It can also help cover up dark circles and make you look more awake.

Q: How do I choose the right shade?

A: Pick a shade that is one or two shades lighter than your natural skin tone. It should match your skin well.

Q: Can I use an under-eye pencil on sensitive skin?

A: Yes, but look for formulas that are hypoallergenic and free of harsh chemicals. Always do a patch test first.

Q: How do I apply it without it looking cakey?

A: Apply a small amount and blend it gently. Don’t rub it in too hard. Use a damp sponge or your fingertip.

Q: Will it crease if I have fine lines?

A: Some formulas are better than others for fine lines. Look for hydrating and creamy formulas. Setting with a light powder can also help.

Q: Can I wear it every day?

A: Yes, most under-eye pencils are safe for daily use. Some even have skincare benefits.

Q: What’s the difference between an under-eye pencil and concealer?

A: An under-eye pencil is typically used for targeted brightening and highlighting. Concealer is usually for covering blemishes or larger areas of discoloration.

Q: How long does an under-eye pencil typically last on the skin?

A: This depends on the formula. Many last for 8-12 hours, especially if they are smudge-proof or waterproof.

Q: Can I use an under-eye pencil to cover pimples?

A: While some pencils might offer coverage, they are specifically designed for the delicate under-eye area. A regular concealer is usually better for pimples.

Q: What if the pencil breaks?

A: If the pencil tip breaks, you can often sharpen it carefully with a makeup sharpener. Be gentle.

Scroll to Top