Top 5 Chicago Pizza Slices: Best Picks Reviewed

Imagine this: you’re in Chicago, the city that practically invented deep-dish pizza. Your stomach rumbles, and you crave a slice. But where do you go? The sheer number of pizzerias can be overwhelming. It’s like trying to find a single perfect star in a sky full of them!

Choosing the best slice of pizza in Chicago is a quest many embark on, and it’s easy to feel lost. Do you want a classic deep-dish, a thin crust masterpiece, or something entirely different? Each bite is an experience, and picking the wrong one can lead to a disappointing meal. We’ve all been there, staring at menus, wondering which pizza will truly satisfy.

Fear not, fellow pizza lovers! This post is your compass in the Windy City’s pizza jungle. We’ll guide you through the essential elements of a great Chicago slice, from the crust to the toppings, and even touch on some legendary spots. By the end, you’ll feel confident in your choice and ready to savor every delicious bite.

Top Slice Of Pizza In Chicago Recommendations

No. 1
The Ultimate Chicago Pizza Guide: A History of Squares & Slices in the Windy City
  • Dolinsky, Steve (Author)
  • English (Publication Language)
  • 312 Pages - 10/15/2021 (Publication Date) - Northwestern University Press (Publisher)
No. 2
Lou Malnati's Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 2-Pack (2 Pepperoni) | Handmade, Restaurant Quality
  • Oven Safe: The pizzas can be baked in the oven for a delicious finish.
  • Dishwasher Safe: The pizzas can be cleaned in the dishwasher for easy maintenance.
  • Deep Dish Pizza: The pizzas have a thick, fluffy crust that holds the toppings.
No. 3
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 6-Pack (3 Cheese 3 Sausage) | Handmade, Restaurant Quality
  • Hand made Chicago deep dish cheese and sausage pizza crafted from scratch by Lou Malnati’s since 1971.
  • Flaky buttery crust, Wisconsin mozzarella, and hand-picked vine-ripened tomatoes.
  • Oven-ready and served hot in about 40 minutes with restaurant-quality taste.
No. 4
Lou Malnati's Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 4-Pack (4 Pepperoni) | Handmade, Restaurant Quality
  • Deep Dish Pizza: Lou Malnati's signature deep dish pizza with a buttery, flaky crust
  • Pepperoni Topping: Classic round pepperoni slices layered on top of the cheese and sauce
  • Oven Safe: Made to go straight from the oven to the table
No. 5
Local Style Potato Chips, Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Flavor – Kettle Cooked & Small Batch –...
  • A SLICE OF CHICAGO IN EVERY CRUNCH. Forget the fork and knife – we turned Chicago’s most famous heavyweight meal into a snack. This isn't just "pizza flavor"; it's Deep Dish. You get the hit of bright, zesty san marzano tomato sauce, a layer of savory spices, a rich, mozzarella cheesy finish, and even notes of the butter crust. It’s the full deep dish flavor without the 45-minute bake time.
  • SMALL BATCH, BOLD KETTLE COOKED CRUNCH. Our small-batch kettle process starts with real USA potatoes, thinly sliced for a bold crunch without the jaw workout – a perfectly golden canvas for Chicago’s famous flavors.
  • VEGETARIAN & GLUTEN-FREE. Deep dish without the drawbacks? We did the impossible. We recreated the rich, cheesy, saucy profile of a deep dish pie using only premium spices and natural ingredients. Real mozzarella cheese, no meat, no gluten, and absolutely no artificials. Finally, a pizza night snack that everyone can agree on.
No. 6
Chicago Pizza Seasoning
  • All Natural Pizza Spice
  • Makes Any Pizza Taste Amazing
  • A Little Goes A Long Way
No. 7
Chicago Brick Oven Pizza Peel, 12" x 14" Aluminum Pizza Paddle, 35.5" Long Pizza Shovel with 21"...
  • EASY HANDLING: Pizza-making process is made easy with our 12-inch by 14-inch pizza turning peel. 21-inch detachable long handle pizza spatula is 35.5-inches long in total. Maneuvering and rotating pizza in a hot oven with our pizza board is a breeze.
  • SAFETY FIRST: Keep fingers burn free with our long pizza peel. Total length of 35.5" makes our pizza turner peel one of the longest on the market. Aluminum pizza peel 14 inch wide is suitable even for extra large pizza sizes.
  • DETACHABLE HANDLE: 21" wooden pizza oven spatula long handle is easily detachable for convenient storage and cleaning. Our turning oven peel makes it easy to transfer pizza, bread, pastries, and pies in and out of indoor and outdoor ovens or grills.
No. 8
Lou Malnati’s Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, 2-Pack (1 Cheese, 1 Spinach) | Handmade, Restaurant Quality
  • Hand made Chicago deep dish cheese and spinach pizza crafted from scratch by Lou Malnati’s since 1971.
  • Flaky buttery crust, Wisconsin mozzarella, and hand-picked vine-ripened tomatoes.
  • Oven-ready and served hot in about 40 minutes with restaurant-quality taste.

Your Guide to the Perfect Chicago Slice

Are you ready for a taste of Chicago? This guide will help you find the best “Slice of Pizza in Chicago.” We’ll talk about what makes a great slice and answer your questions.

What to Look For in a Chicago Slice

Key Features
  • Crust: Chicago pizza is famous for its deep-dish crust. It’s thick, buttery, and often has a slightly crispy bottom. Some places might offer a thinner crust, but deep-dish is the classic.
  • Sauce: The sauce is usually chunky and made with ripe tomatoes. It goes on top of the cheese. This is a big difference from other pizzas!
  • Cheese: Lots of gooey, melted mozzarella cheese is a must. It stretches for days!
  • Toppings: You can get all sorts of toppings. Sausage is very popular. Other good choices include mushrooms, onions, and peppers.
Important Materials

For a pizza, the “materials” are the ingredients.
* Flour: Good quality flour makes a better crust.
* Tomatoes: Fresh, ripe tomatoes create a delicious sauce.
* Cheese: High-quality mozzarella cheese melts perfectly.
* Meats and Veggies: Fresh toppings add great flavor.

Factors That Affect Quality
  • Freshness: Using fresh ingredients makes a big difference.
  • Baking: How long and at what temperature the pizza bakes is important. A perfectly baked crust is golden brown.
  • Skill: The pizza maker’s experience matters. They know how to layer the ingredients just right.
  • Oven Type: Some ovens cook pizza better than others. A hot oven helps create a great crust.
User Experience and Use Cases
  • Eating: Chicago pizza is a meal you eat with a fork and knife. It’s usually very filling!
  • Sharing: A deep-dish pizza is perfect for sharing with friends and family.
  • Occasions: It’s great for a casual dinner, a party, or when you’re craving something hearty and delicious.
  • Takeout: Many places offer takeout, so you can enjoy a Chicago slice at home.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Chicago Slices

Q: What makes Chicago pizza different from New York pizza?

A: Chicago pizza is usually deep-dish with a thick crust, chunky tomato sauce on top, and lots of cheese. New York pizza is thin and foldable, with sauce and cheese on top of the crust.

Q: Do I really need a fork and knife for Chicago pizza?

A: Yes, most people do! Chicago deep-dish pizza is thick and heavy, making it hard to hold like a regular slice.

Q: What are the most popular toppings for Chicago pizza?

A: Italian sausage is a very popular choice. Mushrooms, onions, and green peppers are also common favorites.

Q: Can I get a thin crust Chicago-style pizza?

A: Some places offer a “tavern-style” thin crust pizza, which is also a Chicago favorite. It’s crispy and often cut into squares.

Q: How long does it take to bake a Chicago deep-dish pizza?

A: It usually takes longer than a regular pizza, often around 30-45 minutes, because it’s so thick.

Q: Is Chicago pizza very expensive?

A: Prices can vary depending on the restaurant and the size of the pizza. However, it’s usually a good value because it’s so filling.

Q: Can I freeze leftover Chicago pizza?

A: Yes, you can freeze leftover Chicago pizza. Make sure to wrap it tightly. Reheat it in the oven for the best results.

Q: What are some famous places to get Chicago pizza?

A: Famous spots include Lou Malnati’s, Giordano’s, and Pequod’s Pizza. Many other great pizzerias are around the city too.

Q: Is Chicago pizza healthy?

A: Chicago pizza is generally a treat. It’s high in calories, fat, and carbs due to the deep crust, cheese, and toppings. Enjoy it in moderation!

Q: What’s the best way to reheat Chicago pizza?

A: The oven is best. A toaster oven also works well. Avoid the microwave, as it can make the crust soggy.

Scroll to Top